Posted: Thursday, February 14, 2013 11:31 AM ET
Utility stocks were the fashionable trade of 2011, with the broad-based Utilities Select Sector SPDR (XLU) racking up 14% gains vs. a down market. In 2012, however, utility stocks underperformed significantly, with the XLU fund posting a small loss in the calendar year vs. double-digit gain for the S&P 500.
So are utility stocks back in favor this year? You might think so given the only modest underperformance in January -- the XLU is up 4.3% YTD as of this writing vs. 5.9% for the S&P.
Unfortunately, the sector is grossly overvalued as a whole. According to WSJ Market Data, the Dow’s Utility Index is running hot at a trailing 12-month price-to-earnings ratio of 22.2 -- up dramatically from 14.4 at this time last year.
You might quibble over whether the market in general commands a higher P/E right now based on macro issues or whether individual stocks like Amazon.com (AMZN) still can be a good investment at nosebleed valuations. However, utilities are inherently low-growth stocks with modest historical P/E’s, and there’s no excuse for this kind of premium.
Many things go into stock selection, and I don’t mean to discount the long-term potential of these stocks -- particularly if you have a good cost basis and a robust dividend yield. But these specific picks in the utility sector should be setting off warning bells based on their overpriced valuations:
Southern Company (SO) has a modest trailing P/E of 16.2 and a forward P/E just south of 15 right now, but more importantly, it boasts an inflated five-year PEG ratio of 3.3 thanks to a mere 2% in projected earnings growth for fiscal 2013. The company also trades for twice its book value. The most recent analyst rating on the stock is a “hold” from Deutsche Bank on Jan. 31 with a $45 target -- a measly 3% upside from here -- which was reduced from a previous target of $46 that was only slightly less disappointing. Barclays had a similar message on Jan. 31 with an “equal weight” recommendation, reducing its price target from $48 to $46.
Buy these stocks for a perfectly diversified portfolio
Five great stocks for investors hunting for value
These small-caps could make you wealthy - but be prepared for a wild ride
Three dirt cheap stocks to buy now
Don't miss out on the most important market news delivered daily to your inbox every market morning for FREE!
About Market Intelligence Center |
Contact Us |
Terms of Service
Investors Observer |
Market Intelligence Center |
Fresh Brewed Media News |
S&P Option Strategies |
Fresh Brewed Media
Portions of this content may be copyright by Fresh Brewed Media, Investors Observer, and/or O2 Media LLC. Portions of this content are protected by the following US Patents: 7,716,116; 7,856,390; 7,865,496; 8,463,695; 8,494,944; and 8,676,691.
The most important market news delivered to your inbox every morning!
Click here to see the latest newsletter
Enter your email address: